No worries, reddwarf. I should’ve pointed out that this project was created using AI. It seems that having a tag for this type of projects can definitely avoid some misunderstandings. I hope you have a great day!

Hi ramielrowe. You made great points here. I’m definitely stepping out of my area of expertise. I also understand that when comes to LLM we must not blindly follow/accept things and having some previous knowledge on the topic you intend to work with, gives you much better results and allow you to spot inconsistencies or more importantly, mistakes. I’m aware of the “positive feedback” that is pretty evident specially on ChatGPT, that’s why I try my best to challenge it. I completely understand your analogy on “cognitive debt”. It’s pretty similar to a reinforcing learning process on humans. If you teach people the “wrong way” and keep reinforcing that without any correction, you know the results.

Regarding the code quality, I’m pretty sure it isn’t top notch, that’s why I’m sharing it here so people who really understand it can point out the flaws and suggest improvements. What I’ve learned so far from the feedback in the comments, is that I need to improve the way I communicate my ideas and the purpose of the application. Since this is my first project, and I’m not very familiar with the dev & tech community, I’m learning the do’s and don’ts along the way.

Hi Thaurin, I appreciate your feedback, I understand that security must be a top priority. I’m glad your pointing it out. If you have any advice on how to improve it, it’ll be more than welcome.

That’s right, I’ve been working on this project for a few weeks. I wasn’t sure if I should commit it to a public repo, but I thought it’d nice to have other people testing it out, and giving their opinion. Honestly, I never used github before, that’s why the account is new. I committed everything at once, when I felt like the application was “functional”.

That’s a great question isn’t it? That’s why I posted it here, so maybe I can find people interested in working on this project and help me out to clean things up, get it more organized, structured and “free of AI slop”. What do you think?

Hi Appoxo, I agree that AI can be slop, but it seems like it’s getting better over time. I’m not claiming that this is a revolutionary new application, it’s more like a prove of concept that I wanted to test out. What does it do? well, you basically have a centralized place to keep tracking of your docker images and get a notification when there’s a new release so you can update it manually or automatically as you wish that’s the main utility of it. There are a few other things but, maybe thye aren’t interesting enough.

Hi markko, you’re right, adding a tag would certainly lower expectations and give more clarity to projects. I’ll add this on the post and to the repo.

I won’t stop just because you’re saying it. You can only “know what you’re doing by doing it”. That’s why I made this project public available so anyone interested in looking at it, modifying it, improving it is more than welcome. I’m not selling it or claiming that I’m an expert. Quite the opposite, I’m looking for people who are genuinely interested in exploring new things and helping people out. I’ll rely on the experience and good will of experts of this community.

Thanks man, appreciate it!

Hi @ramielrowe thanks for the feedback, that’s actually pretty good and I’ll start using it. I understand that all this AI thing can be sloppy, and create more friction than good, but I’m really fascinated by how it can help people with little knowledge to build something that a few years ago would’ve been only possible by experts.

I get your point about giving proper credit to the tools involved, and that’s fair. I’m not trying to pass this off as traditional from-scratch coding. Reducing it to “you did nothing” feels a bit excessive. At the same time, there’s still effort in figuring out what to build, iterating, debugging, and getting something functional out. That’s the part I’m happy about.

Hi Dan, I’m also copying the answer from homelab community.

Thanks for your feedback. Much appreciated. For the first question, you click on add and past the image you’re currently using on your compose so the app creates a card with the current version. It’s a bit manual and tedious at first, but once it’s done, it’s easier to maintain. I think your idea is great to have the app just ¨find your docker-compose and do the work", but I don’t know how to do it yet. I wanted to test it manually first and see how it’d work out.

Vigil tells you if the newer version of the image is a major change or not. If you set it to update your compose automatically it will notify you and create a log, it something goes wrong you can easily revert it from the dashboard. Did I get your question right? Let me know if you meant something else.

Finally, security is an absolute must! I decided to use 2FA because most people won’t need to expose it to the web.They’ll probably use it on LAN. However, I do have adding OIDC (OpenID Connect) in mind, since many people indeed use Authentik, Authelia (these are the ones I’m familiar with). Since this is the early version, I didn’t want to make things too complex and also, I’m vibecoding it, so I’ll certainly need some experts out there to help me out to implement it correctly and safely.

If you have any question, just let me know and I’ll try my best to answer that.

It’s not a bad idea at all to have a label so we could set expectations right. But don’t be too harsh on me ;) Just being able to pull a functional app without much of experience is already a reasonable accomplishment is it?

Absolutelly vibecoding it with Cloude. I understand a bit of python and html but I’m no dev or technical professional at all. I just wanted to see if I could build something useful without much of technical expertise.

Thanks brother, I appreciate it. Security is one of my main concerns too, that’s why I’ll rely on the experts around here to point out what could be improved.

Yeah, absolutely. You can set the notifications as you wish.

Yeah that’s exactly what I was thinking about when I started this project. I’ve noticed that many home labers are a bit skeptical with automatic updates. I’m glad you liked the idea

Well, I’m no tech expert at all so I’m just trying to get things right. I might not be able to answer everything, but I’ll do my best to get you an answer.

Yeah absolutely, my bad. First time publishing things here and I thought it was attached to the post. https://github.com/kumucode/vigil.git