I needed a genuine feedback yesterday I shared my movie first look here and asked everyone to give me a review but majority of the people simply started bashing and giving invalid pure hatred reviews I just want to ask y’all did you even watched the trailer at here https://dai.ly/xa79kra if not better not give any unnecessary critique of yours if you haven’t even watched it I be happy to take genuine feedback rather than blind pure hatred for ai if y’all hate it this much why you use it in your daily life stop using it and y’all acting like making videos with ai is easy you need a professional prompt and also use various different softwares pay subscription to get them to talk it’s not that easy if anyone of you can even create what I did in single day then I will happily accept my defeat talking is easy than actually doing something.
You must log in or register to comment.
Your trailer would be trash no matter if it’s made by AI or not. Who is going to sit through minutes of “introducing” a whole bunch of characters. Like am I supposed to take notes? Will there be a test?
I get that you are still starting out, but writing is hard and good writing is valued very highly. Did you write anything for your movie? Or were you just vibing out some characters? In a good story the characters would be introduced in a natural way. Your style might sorta work in a heist kind of movie where shit gets literally explained to someone (and thus the audience), where you can have some sort of establishing shot (perhaps with a zoom) and a voice-over (by somebody we already know) that explains something about the heist, location, procedures or related people.
If you want to make a movie, don’t start with the trailer. Start with writing a story, make it a short movie and thus a short story. Then storyboard that story, see what works and what doesn’t. Perhaps re-write the story in the form of a screenplay, but that could also be done at a later point in the process. Then start thinking about visuals, what to show, what not to show (often more important).
This is why so many people hate AI. It allows shortcuts that shouldn’t be there. Just because the AI could generate the visuals (al be it not at a proper level in my opinion at this point), doesn’t mean you can just skip the story part or the screenplay part or the direction part etc.
And you also fall into the trap of “I created this in a day”. Just because it was fast to create doesn’t mean it inherently has more value, in fact I would say it has inherently less value. It also isn’t like with a lot of things where if you do something quickly you get a small result and if you put more time into it the result gets better. Like when cleaning your house, just clearing some stuff away is good, but putting in a full day of intensive cleaning is better. With AI it’s really easy to hit a ceiling. This is as good as it’s going to get, no matter how much more time you put into it. And people find it wanting. So just because you created this in a day, doesn’t mean it’s somehow a masterpiece if you were to put in 100 days. It would still be a mess.
I watched your trailer and found it to be an incoherent mess.
It plays like a series of unrelated character intros with nothing tying it together. The music isn’t consistent nor the voice over. No throughline to follow.
Also did you steal the music from Knight Rider? It seems to pop in randomly for one of the scenes.
I suggest you watch some movie trailers and look for how they tie it all together to make a story.
Nice run-on sentence. Did AI write your post too?
if y’all hate it this much why you use it in your daily life
A hammer can be used to build a house.
A hammer can also be used to break every window on a house.
I don’t think people on an AI community hate AI and therefore hate your project, I think they just hate the project you have made.
This is probably because there is no sensible narrative, a lack of interesting cinematography, awful music that cuts in and out at weird times, weird cuts that don’t flow, no real dialogue, etc.
As a film I couldn’t tell anyone what it is about or why they should watch it based on the trailer - the entire point of a trailer is to establish this.
This isn’t so much poor AI as it is extremely poor film making.
Not saying your movie will be bad, but that trailer was really bad.
Audio was all over place, no continuity, and a bunch of obvious flaws or things that don’t make sense videos.
I feel like AI could potentially be used in experimental films, but you probably at a minimum need consistent character LoRAs and to use something like WAN Animate or SCAIL to get meaningful motion and reactions.
It also needs a good story of course. 8f the story if actually good, you don’t need visuals and could just write a book. But poor, incoherrrent visuals could also distrace from a mediocre story too
First of all that’s 2mins it’s not a movie. I’ll give some feedback as if it’s a trailer for a movie.
Don’t introduce so many characters in the trailer just give a teaser of what the plot will be.
The shots are to similar, every shot can’t be a zoom in shot of a person looking into the camera. Need to mix it up with some side shots or panning actions shots.
Blending the shots together. They should lead into each other. The timing the beat the little story you’re telling it should flow from one beat to the next.
