When I heard Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2019 was back in the limelight thanks to an unusually steep $6 sale on Steam, I wasn’t too surprised. Infinity Ward’s Modern Warfare reboot was extremely popular in its day, reinvigorating a series that tread water through the mid-2010s and ushering in an era of followups that’d build on its reimagined progression and class systems.

MW2019 was the best these games had ever played, looked, or sounded at the time. Coming back to it now, it’s obvious Call of Duty hasn’t been meaningfully better since.

I’m reminded that this was Call of Duty redoubling down on grounded “realism” after years of wallrunning and jetpacks. Infinity Ward harnessed the immersive presentational qualities of a milsim within the confines of an arcadey shooter, and it’s just as effective now as it was then. It’s worth pointing out that this past streak of games helmed by Treyarch, Sledgehammer, and Raven just do not sound or look like this, even when it’s clear they’re trying to get close.

When folks say Infinity Ward’s games are better made than Treyarch’s, this is the stuff they’re talking about. This game really checked all the boxes—excellent gunplay, memorable maps, sticky progression, and a campaign that doesn’t suck (though that Highway of Death mission sure does).